When establishing a style of play, all top-level managers face the same pragmatic questions: How will positional defenders become functional attackers (and vice versa) as changes in possession occur? Where is the balance between earnest advancement and cautious reserve? And how is that equilibrium expressed, implicitly and explicitly, on the team sheet?
On paper, solutions seem simpler; the use of wing backs or outside backs, extra center backs or designated defensive midfielders all infer something different about offensive and defensive posture. But a football formation guarantees performance about as much as a tennis star’s stance ensures a serve is aced or returned (meaning, it doesn’t… not on its own, anyways). And while the location of names on a projected pitch says one thing, mid-match, a side’s tendencies may be operationally accomplished in a less presumptive manner by expression of players’ unique strengths, planned alterations which enhance both individual contributions and tactical nuance while accessing the desirable aspects of multiple “formations” all at once.
At Euro 2020, Italy have been a strong illustration of this principle in action. While they have been relatively consistent in their approach throughout the competition, let’s look below at the structural propensities which drove Italy’s quarterfinal victory over Belgium.
To begin, both sides maintained their usual starting formations: Italy (white X) lined up in a 4-3-3 and Belgium (red/yellow O) in a 3-4-2-1. And though each sought to occupy different spaces when in and out of possession, Italy arguably posed the greater challenge to their opponent’s defensive solidarity. One major reason for this dissimilarity was Italy’s progressive repositioning, and adjustments made possible in part by Belgium’s preference for a less energetic press. With possession secured, the Italians quickly reshaped (blue arrows): Spinazzola (left back), more often than Di Lorenzo (right back), pushed into the opponent’s half while the rest of the backline rebalanced as a triad. This opened passing lanes for drop balls, and mitigated Belgium’s threat on the counter. Insigne (left winger) drifted unpredictably, either taking up a position alongside Immobile (center forward) or picking up the ball around midfield to start the attack. Chiesa (right winger) notably stayed wide, stretching the Belgian backline, occupying the opposition left wing back, and playing to his strengths as a 1v1 dribbler with support from Barella (central midfielder). All things considered, Italy in possession could be better characterized as a 3-1-5-1 or 3-5-2 (right diagram), a remarkable conversion from 4-3-3 and impressive display of tactical fluidity.
More and more, we see world class managers disregarding precedence in favor of strategy, differentiating responsibilities of positional enantiomers or recasting talented players in uncharacteristic roles, with the ultimate reward being realized when the whole is so much greater than the sum of its parts. The implications are extensive: formations become formalities, lineups appear misleading, and humdrum team rosters eclipse all-star casts. Suddenly, the match at hand turns out to be just the visible iceberg above a submerged colossus of technical and tactical identity. And football is all the better for it.
you might also enjoy…
Since arriving at Manchester United in the summer of 2018, Fred has been under a microscope with each and every passing minute. Every action he takes on a football pitch seems to be scrutinized by those trying to justify his shortcomings, or those, like me, trying to justify why those shortcomings aren’t actually so short. In recent weeks, the calls for Fred to be crowned one of United’s most important players have only grown, as he performs a more attack-minded role within the team’s double-pivot. So today, I present to you a dossier all about Manchester United’s Fred, and why Manchester United would be worse without him.
This week on a special combo review and preview podcast, John and Declan are joined again by Brennan McCaffray to talk about the Merseyside derby, United’s win against Arsenal, and the London derby between Chelsea and West Ham this weekend!
Newcastle United, after 12 games, are yet to register a win in the Premier League this season, and face the very real prospect of relegation to the Championship. But after securing new billionaire ownership at the start of October, the club is doing everything it can to avoid the drop. With hundreds of millions of dollars being pumped into the club, the Magpies now have a considerable war chest to bolster their squad during the upcoming January Transfer Window. But as January draws closer, Eddie Howe’s team continue to sit rock bottom in the table, dangerously close to making their situation unrecoverable.