York United vs. Cavalry FC – Tactical Preview

Just two weeks into the Canadian Premier League’s fourth season, one thing is clear. The talent on the football pitch, from both a playing, and tactical perspective is extraordinarily high. So much so, that much of the punditry and commentary surrounding second-place Atletico Ottawa has continuously failed to truly nail down Gonzalez’s complex team shape in and out of possession. So much so, that Pacific FC are pulling off attacking rotations that most teams wouldn’t dare to try. As the league now heads into its third set of matches, optimism and attention over the league has never been higher. So with that, we take a tactical glance at each and every match in week three. We begin with the tactical battle between Martin Nash’s York United and Tommy Wheeldon Jr.’s Cavalry FC, who currently sit level on points and goal differential. Here is our analysis.


York United’s start to the season has failed to be as fruitful as the Nine Stripes would have liked, but Martin Nash’s team showed marked improvements against FC Edmonton in providing more attacking thrust than the opening day against HFX. Developing a sense of identity with fullbacks pushing high up the pitch and attacking rotations between their striker and attacking midfielder, York’s 4-2-3-1 formation should contain two crucial elements required for breaking Cavalry down.

The Cavs don’t tend to allow space in between their defensive and midfield lines, with Victor Loturi and Charlie Trafford magnificently screening and compacting central areas. Instead, the space tends to be on the outside of the centre-backs, where Karifa Yao is often asked to step out of position and sweep up the mess.

But York’s rotations could disrupt their sound positioning and central compaction, forcing Cavalry’s defense into a difficult decision. That is the classic – stick or twist? Or in football words – follow movement in deep or hold position? If they persist in stepping up to defend, like Edmonton did at the weekend, they will leave gaps that can then be exploited. As both Nyal Higgins and Luke Singh found out on Friday, stepping out of position can become detrimental if the ball is not recovered, and the gaps are not immediately condensed by teammates closest to the situation.

York didn’t create many clear-cut chances of note against Alan Koch’s defense, but their best moments always came when they pulled at least one centre-back out of position.

In disrupting the defensive structures all the more, York’s movement up front between Johnston and De Rosario could also cause Cavalry into fouls, such as Forge’s use of Terran Campbell to bully both Karifa Yao and Daan Klomp into yellow cards.

Additionally, utilizing N’Sa and Abzi to get high up the pitch and deliver crosses into the box will be imperative. York should target overloads down the wing and look to go 2v1 against Cavalry’s fullbacks, before seeking space in between outside-centre-back and wing-back. Neither Johnston or De Rosario could be described as a “focal point” up front, and so York need to provide greater execution to their deliveries than they managed against a stern Edmonton defense. Their most troublesome cross on the day came from a low-driven delivery, again as a centre-back (Nyal Higgins) stepped out of position. Given the aerial dominance of players like Karifa Yao and Daan Klomp, using low-driven deliveries or cut-backs could be the best approach as opposed to those overhit crosses they pumped toward the back-post. Regardless, having played against a back three in Edmonton on Friday, York should be bursting with ideas as to how they can break down a 5-4-1 defensive structure. Then it’s just about execution, and the small tactical tweaks based on the evolution of the match, and how well Cavalry work to combat their game-plan.

Cavalry on the other hand haven’t quite clicked from an attacking perspective, despite scoring 2 goals against Forge. It’s their defensive solidity that’s been more impressive, limiting Forge to two worldies, and completely stunting the Hammers’ penetration through the thirds. In getting more out of their attacking quality, Joe Mason should be asked to run the channels more, and adapt his game to become more than just where we have him classified right now – as a “Fox in the Box“. Between his two matches so far, the Mason has only accumulated a combined 40 touches. To bring that into context, Forge’s Achinioti-Jönsson had 104 touches in this weekend’s match alone. Confusingly from a Cavalry perspective, one of their best passages of play against Atletico occurred when Daan Klomp floated a long pass into the channel, that Joe Mason excellently brought down before being fouled by Diego Espejo.

Ali Musse meanwhile is an exceptional dribbler who could easily benefit from being able to bounce one-two’s off of a man who clearly has the capacity to play as a target, link, and channel runner all wrapped in one. There’s a clear discrepancy between the evident quality Joe Mason has in his locker, to what he’s being asked to do in possession phases – essentially stay central, push the opposition’s defensive line back as others magic instead, and poach goals. This is of course an over-simplification, but on statistics alone, you’d probably guess that he played fifteen or so minutes in both games, rather than 176.

Importantly from a tactical perspective, there’s a noticeable difference in threat level between the two centre-forwards York’s defensive line have faced so far. On the opening day, Joao Morelli’s meticulous movement pulled Dominick Zator and Roger Thompson out of position and out of sorts. Morelli constantly worked to create room to strike from range, pick up the ball and drive forward, and crucially to creating chances, he combined excellently well with runners from midfield. Against Edmonton, Zator and Thompson had an easier time dealing with the more stagnant Julian Ulbricht – who rarely ventured out of central attacking areas. As a consequence, Joe Mason simply needs to get more involved, bringing out the best in players normally asked to work their magic instead (like Ali Musse). If he can make himself a nuisance, win fouls for his team and provide greater attacking connectivity in the attacking third, York United will have a difficult time handling Cavalry on the night.

So there it is! Our quick-take tactical analysis of the upcoming match between York and Cavalry in the Canadian Premier League. Be sure to check out more of our CPL articles, and don’t forget to check back in a few days time for the remaining previews. Also be sure to follow on social media to never miss an update @mastermindsite! Thanks for reading and see you soon!

Success! You're on the list.


Canadian Premier League Matchday 5 – Tactical Review

This season in the Canadian Premier League, Rhys Desmond will be bringing you the tactical minutiae behind every single match, team, and moment. Here is our tactical review of the Canadian Premier League’s fifth round of fixtures!

Canadian Premier League – Player Ratings

After the first week of action in the 2022 Canadian Premier League season, we have officially launched our brand new Player Evaluation System. The details of this can be found in this article – Evaluating players based on role continuity, and we have already begun the process of identifying roles for specific players that may have stood out on the day. Here are how the players of the Canadian Premier League currently rank based on our brand new model.

How Cavalry’s staggered shape stunned Edmonton – Match Analysis

The Cavs started the season in a 3-4-2-1 formation, suffering two embarrassing losses to York and Atletico, and a stagnant draw against Forge. After realizing the slow-moving car wasn’t quite motoring the way he wanted it to, even despite the gas pedal being pressed, Wheeldon Jr. was right to identify a new vehicle. Now in a flexible 4-4-2 shape, Cavalry have been utterly dominant in both of their matches since, both in and out of possession. On this particular occasion, they completely stunted Edmonton’s progress going forward, and massively exploited space in exactly the right areas through staggering their personnel across the pitch. Here is a quick tactical analysis of Cavalry’s commanding 3-0 win over FC Edmonton.

Why patterns and context are so essential to analysis in football

If you’re reading this article, chances are you love to analyze football. So allow me to help with your love for analysis with this call to action. Stop taking information from single-match occurrences, or single-match statistics, even statistics over time on their own, as a mechanism for making inferences about the wider context at hand. Recognizing patterns over time, and the wider context behind those patterns, are the essentials behind analysis in football, allowing you to more accurately assess performance, and improve upon performance problems.

Canadian Premier League Matchday 4 – Tactical Review

We may be four matches in now, but the Canadian Premier League continues to show no signs of slowing down, with four goals scored in both of the weekend’s fixtures so far, balancing out a dull midweek affair between Edmonton and Pacific. Ahead of the final two fixtures, here is our ongoing tactical review of Week 4 inside the Canadian Premier League.

5 thoughts on “York United vs. Cavalry FC – Tactical Preview

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s