Barcelona have been on a deep, downward spiral ever since rumours of Messi’s departure started to surface toward the end of the 2019-20 season. The La Liga giants have won just the 2020-21 Copa del Rey since the 2018-19 season, and now look destined to finish below a UEFA Champions League place this time around. Xavi Hernandez has come into the club to try and restore normality, but with the club floundering under uncertainty of poor budget planning and insufficient funds, Xavi’s task appears to be a mammoth one. Barcelona sit in just sixth place at the moment, and they’ve had very few convincing performances since the former Barca legend arrived from Al Sadd. With young players not quite ready and old heads no longer at their best ruling the starting lineup, Xavi’s ability to find consistency before the end of the season could be impossible. So with that, let’s take a look at some of the tactics Xavi has deployed since taking over the helm at Camp Nou, and what needs to change if the legend is get his team back into the UEFA Champions League next season.
SYSTEM OF PLAY: 4-3-3
Barcelona’s lack of consistency shows in the fact that thirty-four different players have accumulated minutes this season in La Liga. Half of those men are 22 years of age or under, and five are under the age of 18. Xavi’s preference toward youth is partially down to what he has at his disposal, but also partially down to wanting to give young players a chance to shine – particularly in attacking roles. He’s overdone this to an extent, with Barcelona becoming reliant on players that are not yet ready to deliver the goods.
In fact, if you take the likes of Andre ter Stegen, Sergio Busquets, Frenkie de Jong and Memphis Depay out of the team, you’re probably left with a bottom half of the table team. The likes of Dani Alves and Jordi Alba no longer have the legs to do the excellent work off the ball they could achieve in the early 2010s, and Barcelona are having to rely on their shape and structure to avoid serious calamities. In a pacier, more powerful league like the German Bundesliga, they’d probably be scrapping just above the relegation zone. So normally this is the section where we talk about the players that Xavi has deployed within his 4-3-3 since taking over. But instead, we’re going to make suggestions for how he should progress in a world where all players are fit.Embed from Getty Images
First, Xavi needs to stop relying on the likes of Gavi, Nico Gonzalez, Ferran Jutgla and Abdessamad Ezzalzouli. These players are all fine to make cameo appearances and earn minutes when the time is right, but they cannot be consistent starters for a team fighting for Champions League football at this time. Youngsters like Sergino Dest, Pedri and Ansu Fati have a bit more experience under their belt and should be favoured instead when available.Embed from Getty Images
Secondly, Xavi needs to stop relying on the older heads that he knows well from his time as a player. Dani Alves could do excellent work and seemingly has better fitness levels than the ‘how is he still playing?’ slowness of Jordi Alba on the other side. Realistically, Barcelona are so bad right now that Alves could probably be one of the best players in the team. But, Xavi has a player in Sergino Dest who should have already nailed down that starting spot. Dest can be a useful option further forward, but his best position will be as a right back. It will be awesome for Dest’s to develop to learn from the man he was brought in to emulate, but it won’t be as good for his development to do that learning from the bench. If anything, the 38-year-old Brazilian can come into the right-side of central midfield if Frenkie de Jong and Pedri are both out, which would allow Alves to limit his defensive responsibilities and just focus on his excellence with the ball at his feet. Jordi Alba should be out of the squad completely if Barcelona are going to continue with a back-four, as the Spaniard’s legs to get back and defend are absolutely shattered. He’s useful in attack and times his runs forward well, but he’s creating a massive issue for his team going the other way. Xavi could experiment with an Al Sadd styled 3-4-3, but if he deploys Sergio Busquets as the sweeper and utilizes the ball progression of de Jong and Pedri in midfield, it’s essentially the same system as the 4-3-3.Embed from Getty Images
Gerard Pique meanwhile could easily be replaced by Ronald Araujo and Eric Garcia at this point. Then you have a player like Marc-Andre ter Stegen, who doesn’t look the same confident goalkeeper we saw years ago, but remains the best option. Sergio Busquets should be the first name on the team sheet when Frenkie de Jong isn’t fit, as he continues to anchor a young midfield excellently well. But Xavi needs to get Frenkie and Pedri back to full fitness to complete his midfield triangle and allow for better connection between the midfield and forward lines in possession.Embed from Getty Images
In the final third, Xavi needs to put an arm around Ousmane Dembele and tell him to express himself and take risks. Dembele looks a shadow of his former Dortmund self, taking shots from deep nearly every time he receives the ball in the attacking third, when he has the dribbling quality of a Jadon Sancho. Barca also need to provide better service into the target man that is Luuk de Jong if they’re going to persist with him up front, otherwise…why play him? Memphis Depay or Ferran Torres should be the striker if they’re not going to deliver crosses or use de Jong with his back to goal. If they are going to use both Dutchmen in the squad, Depay would make for an excellent option off the left to support his compatriot. But realistically, Ferran Torres will make for a much better player up front, and massively help with linking the forward and midfield lines with his false nine qualities.
So when considering all this potential change, Xavi has a lot of work to do. But persisting with seventeen and eighteen year old prospects is simply not the way he’s going to get Barca back into the Champions League. So with that, let’s now take a greater look at Xavi’s tactics, and what he could improve in the quest to get his team back to the level they desire.
IN POSSESSIONEmbed from Getty Images
Xavi’s 4-3-3 system quickly takes on various different forms in attack, as you’d expect from a team deploying a possession-based version of this popular system of play. Positional play is always integral to what Xavi’s teams look to do within their tiki-taka based possession. Fullbacks will invert with wingers or central midfielders wide (usually both), and vice versa. They work the wide areas and look to create overloads like no tomorrow, with several players drifting over to one side. The idea behind this would to either outnumber the opposition and then play an incisive pass down the line; or to isolate their opposition on the other side and switch play. The problem for Xavi is that Barcelona have been incredibly ineffective in both regards. Their switches of play are far too slow and readable, and their incisive passes down the line often end with a player drifting into an offside position. On other occasions, they work the ball into the wide area, overload one side, and then don’t actually take advantage of the overload before quickly (but slowly) switching play to the other side and allowing the opposition to shift across. They then make pointless sideways passes on a one-touch back and forth toward the halfway line, with the opposition wondering the entire time – ‘So what else can you do?’.Embed from Getty Images
The answer to the solution? Xavi’s Barcelona simply need to be more direct. Luuk de Jong is one of the best target men around. If you’re not going to use him like a target man and give him service, there’s no point in playing him. Further, if you’re going to use players who haven’t quite developed yet and lack the elegance when it comes to the final ball into the box, there’s even less of a point. Barca’s latest goal against Granada came with 34-year-old Alba dribbling the ball in-field, passing the ball to 38-year-old Alves and then continuing to make a shadow run as Alves prepared his cross to the big man up top. This is the kind of thing Barcelona should be looking to do more. Stop the slow methodical passes around between the centre-backs, and give de Jong something to work with, or even Depay something to chase. Ferran Torres drifting in deep to pick up possession will be another way Barcelona can combat this, and the Spaniard would be a welcomed addition into the team.Embed from Getty Images
They could also be more direct in utilizing Dembele’s trickery out wide. If the Frenchman could just get a little bit of confidence in his game, he could be a brilliant player. But for now, he’s receiving the ball, cutting onto his left foot, and striking from 25 yards out when better options are available. Besides, it becomes very easy for the opposition to double-team Dembele when the rest of the team is young and completely out of sync. They desperately need the ball progression of Frenkie de Jong and Pedri back into the team, and should be praying on all of their wishes to god that those two will be back in no time.
BUILD-UPEmbed from Getty Images
Xavi Hernandez’s team build out from the back with the fullbacks typically low, and a 4+1 structure most common. The central midfielders will also remain relatively low, as the team then look to move up the field together on their one and two touch passing. Close proximity helps massively in a tiki taka style, but it also invites greater pressure toward the team’s own goal. Ter Stegen is capable with the ball at his feet and decent at finding the right times to play forward, but again, Barca could simply go long into their striker’s path more often, especially if Depay can take advantage of knock downs and sprint in behind. You’re probably reading this going – ‘Yeah, but Rhys, it’s not the Barcelona identity.’ If it’s not the Barcelona identity, then what are you doing with Luuk de Jong in the first place?
PROGRESSIONEmbed from Getty Images
Once progressing into the opposition’s half, Dani Alves and Jordi Alba will typically take turns in venturing forward, with Sergio Busquets always holding and ready to cover for his out of position mates. The two outside central midfielders will often drift wide to compound matters, allowing their fullbacks to go on the underlap. A 2-4-4 is a common shape in this phase, with one centre-mid higher than the other, as Barcelona play their sideways passes and take hopeful shots from distance. This is also where their wide overloads begin to take form, but they will also utilize forward bounce passes in the progression phase, looking for players at the very front of their attack to bounce the ball back from the centre-backs into central midfielders operating slightly lower. They’ve been slightly more effective at utilizing these ideas to create chances than their abysmal switches of play, which again showcases the need for a quicker, more vertical style. For now, we’ll stake our claim as the ones who used the term ‘possession with a purpose’ to catch Mark Carey’s eye on The Athletic, and say that Barcelona are simply a team that keep possession without a purpose.
OUT OF POSSESSIONEmbed from Getty Images
Most of the good work Xavi has done so far at Barcelona has been with his team off the ball and out of possession. This matters when they have one of the slowest defensive units around, and so the Spaniard should be commended for the shape and structure he’s built.
When pressing, or rather blocking high, Barcelona frequently deploy a 4-1-3-2 shape. Gavi will join the striker as part of the front two, and Busquets will step up almost in line with the other three to make it a 4-4-2. They allow space in between the lines when they block high, with the strikers far ahead of the midfielders in behind. We discussed this ideology in our recent analysis of Brighton, positing that leaving space can allow the opposition to move into positions further away from goal. The obvious downside is that it makes a team like Barcelona, who don’t press from the front as well as Brighton, open and easy to expose. They’ve improved under Xavi in this regard, now with the second most successful press in the league. So why they don’t ramp up their intensity and desire is a bit puzzling. For example, when losing the ball in the final third, Xavi’s team simply back off when they could counter-press instead. Surely it would be more advantageous to win the ball back closer to their opposition’s goal? But Barcelona instead save their energy for their in-possession moments, knowing they’re relying on a mix of incredibly old and incredibly young players who are either over or under their peak of physical fitness. What it represents from a tactical perspective is a lack of hunger for the ball until the opposition reach Barca’s defensive third. With La Liga being a slower, possession-based league, the approach is ultimately a fair one to take.Embed from Getty Images
In the wide areas, Xavi’s side may use those overloads to then step up their counter-press, and they will often look to keep their opposition out wide and overload again in 2v1’s. Central midfielders will frequently come out wide to help their fullbacks, and if wingers are diligent in tracking back then they can stop the opposition from creating overloads of their own. That means further down the pitch in their mid-block, the shape will look more like a 4-1-4-1, with Gavi firmly back into midfield, helping his left-back more than his striker. Busquets does an excellent job in this phase at screening the opposition’s striker and limiting central progression, practically playing as a third centre-back. The 33-year-old doesn’t have to do an awful lot of actionable items out of possession in truth, with most of the work done around him as he slides around to always be in the right place when it matters most. The idea would then be to force shots from deep, the kind Barcelona seem to love to hit from range in the attacking plans of their own. But they’ve been fairly ineffective at actually accomplishing this, with one of the highest percentages of shots in their own six-yard-box, and one of the lowest in percentage of shots against from range. This is all to say that while Xavi has made improvements, Barcelona could simply be far better out of possession, and there is still a massive amount of work to do in seeing his defensive principles fully come to life.
CONCLUSIONEmbed from Getty Images
Barcelona have been bad this season. There’s no way around it. Xavi’s team have achieved some decent results and rarely lost, but nearly every single one of their wins has been marginal at best, and the team still struggle to form any real consistency both in personnel and tactics. We suggest Xavi not be afraid to deploy a more direct, vertical style of play, especially with Luuk de Jong in the team. We also suggest the Spanish manager stop relying so much on players who have come straight out of the academy, and look to get the likes of Araujo, Frenkie de Jong and Pedri back into the team as soon as possible. Otherwise, Barcelona are destined to finish outside the top four for the first time in decades.
So there it is! A tactical analysis of Xavi Hernandez’s Barcelona after eleven games in charge. Be sure to check out more of our tactical analyses, and follow on social media @mastermindsite via the links below. Thanks for reading and see you soon!
want to play like GUARDIOLA’S MAN CITY?
PURCHASE OUR 4-3-3 GAME MODEL EXAMPLE –
They are not to be taken literal, although ideas can certainly be taken from this resource and implemented within your own team’s system and style of play. This game model example showcases what Rhyspect FC looks to do in each third of the pitch in all three defensive phases, and all three attacking phases. The game model also provides a brief look into set-pieces and player characteristics.
YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY…
Gerrard remains a relatively inexperienced manager, but with a clear sense of tactical knowhow, the former Liverpool legend appears to be long for this world. Gerrard’s won four from his first ten in charge, and added his first draw to the mix this past weekend against Manchester United with an extraordinary comeback. New additions in Lucas Digne and Philippe Coutinho have also entered the frame, providing the perfect time to take a look at how Gerrard has settled into life at Villa Park so far. Here is our tactical analysis of Steven Gerrard’s Aston Villa in 2021-22.
With the lowest xG in the league, Eddie Howe has a difficult conundrum to solve. But with sound principles of play in possession in place and two new additions, Newcastle should be able to get out alive this season. Here is our analysis of Eddie Howe’s 4-3-3.
AS Roma and Paulo Fonseca parted ways with the Italian giants finishing just seventh in Serie A, but a more positive semi-final run in the Europa League and some encouraging attack-minded, tactically intriguing football. Legend of the game Jose Mourinho was the man to come in and replace Fonseca, and the Portuguese icon got off to a flying start in his Roma career, winning six from the first seven. But since then, it’s been typical Mourinho, with the club now potentially spiraling back into their old ways. This week I talk to Roma expert Edward Stratmann on what needs to happen if Mourinho is to change the club’s fortunes around, and the tactics Mourinho has displayed since taking over from Fonseca. Be sure to follow the show @mastermindsite, and give Edward a shout using the links below.
After the departure of Nuno Espirito Santo at the end of last season, Wolverhampton Wanderers hoped their next manager would have the gusto to turn the club back into a Europa League challenging team. While Bruno Lage wasn’t the flashiest of appointments, the Portuguese manager has surpassed fan expectations, turning Wolves into one of the best defensive units in the league. Despite scoring just 14 goals in 19 league games, Wolves sit 8th place in the table, on 28 points. That in large part is due to the excellent tactical balance of Bruno Lage’s team, their sound defensive structure, and the fact that every single player has completely bought into his ideologies. Here is a tactical analysis all about Bruno Lage’s Wolves.
Antonio Conte’s Spurs, as expected, have gotten off to a flying start. Conte’s team have gone unbeaten in their eight Premier League matches so far, playing some fantastic, easy on the eye football in the process. The variety in their attacking play has helped the team to 14 goals in 8 matches, with just 5 conceded in the process. In our recent analysis of Conte’s team, we posited that the team only had one key dilemma to solve – what to do against low-blocks who want to sit very deep against them. As opposition teams sort Tottenham out, Conte’s quest to combat the low-block appears to be growing all the more difficult by the match. They failed to claim victory against 10-man Southampton earlier in the week, and yesterday had to wait until stoppage time for Davinson Sanchez’s winner. So with that, we take a quick look at how teams like Antonio Conte’s can disrupt a low-block and generate scoring chances, taking examples from Spurs’ own 1-0 victory against Watford at the weekend.
One of the most tactically complex teams in world football, no other team could change formation and personnel to the extent that Graham Potter’s Brighton do without suffering any consequences. Through all the constant change, it’s miraculous to think his team have boasted some of the best possession in the league, and one of the soundest defensive structures. The calls continue to come for Potter to move up a level and take on a new challenge, but for now, the British manager has kept Brighton in the top half of the table for the vast majority of the 2021-22 season. Here is our tactical analysis of Graham Potter’s incredible Brighton & Hove Albion.
It is now two months since Antonio Conte put pen to paper with Tottenham Hotspur, and the signs of improvement are clear. Spurs sit fourth in the table as things stand, in with a real shout of reclaiming Champions League football after three seasons away. Meanwhile, just about every player has upped their game under the influence of the Italian, most importantly, Harry Kane – who is finally firing in front of goal again. So as Conte gets accustomed to his role and his newly inherited squad, we take a look at the Italian’s tactics with Tottenham so far in 2021-22.