Is the deep-lying playmaker a dying breed?

Embed from Getty Images

Defensive midfielders have rarely been the flashiest of players.

Embed from Getty Images

Typically tasked with the simplest of actions and holding their position at the heart of the midfield, it’s typically their midfield partners who garner all the acclaim.

Embed from Getty Images

Even the best of the modern game are rarely rewarded with the applause and the awards they deserve, as those with all the goals and assists receive the praise.

Embed from Getty Images

But there’s a genuine argument to suggest that this is one of the most important positions on the pitch.

A truly great defensive midfielder can control a midfield all on their own.

Embed from Getty Images

As teams push their talented playmakers further forward, gaps in the midfield will naturally form. These gaps can be exploited in changes of possession, where the defensive midfielder now must act as the first line of pressure.

Those like Casemiro and Busquets who can cover spaces through game savviness and intelligence, are just as important as those that do so with the mobility to gallop around the pitch, like N’Golo Kanté or Moisés Caicedo.

Embed from Getty Images

For the deep-lying playmaker, this is still imperative to their role. They might be more focused on the principles in possession. But they might also be critical to everything their teams do in defense, particularly in breaking up the play in the lower third, and cutting out counter attacks before they can even begin.

But as that defensive presence grows and more midfielders become all-action packed and capable of fulfilling multiple roles, the truest forms of the ‘deep-lying playmaker’ are becoming a dying breed.

The likes of Rodri, Elliot Anderson, and Bruno Guimaraes could all be considered within this modern mold of the deep-lying playmaker. But when you think of all three, you think of mobility, energy, intensity, and aggression, as much as anything they do with the ball.

Embed from Getty Images

This is why we’re entering a phase of football where midfield roles are becoming blurred. Modern midfielders can do it all. In just about every team, they can all play as a ‘6’ or an ‘8’ – covering both the defensive and possession responsibilities all in one.

Embed from Getty Images

If they don’t check all the boxes, they’re often criticized for what they lack. For example, Casemiro always played an underrated role at Manchester United for his defensive aptitude and physicality. He was never the best ball-playing midfielder, but he always knew where to be on the pitch to break up the attack. But he still often received criticism for his missteps in possession or his supposed lack of mobility.

Embed from Getty Images

Meanwhile, ball-savvy midfielder Adam Wharton was left out of the England squad for not providing that same physicality and defensive presence as his counterparts – Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson.

Embed from Getty Images

With every midfielder now looking to emulate Declan Rice’s versatility, those growing up in that ‘deep-lying playmaker role’ of today have to be careful not to fall into a specialized trap in a modern game of generalists.

Embed from Getty Images

The likes of Tyler Morton and Billy Gilmour are being shipped out of England to other leagues, where their passing quality and ability to control a game can shine, in spite of their lack of physicality.

Embed from Getty Images

Meanwhile, the likes of Youri Tielemans and Adam Wharton are being prioritized further forward, which is much more to do with what they don’t offer in defense, than what they provide in attack.

Embed from Getty Images

Others like Zubimendi and Bouaddi are having trouble breaking into the first eleven since others offer more muscle.

Embed from Getty Images

Part of this has also stemmed from the gradual shift across the past couple decades toward playing out from the back, and ball-playing centre-backs. The top passers in any division are now the likes of Rúben Dias and Jan Paul Van Hecke rather than coming from midfield.

Embed from Getty Images

Modern day teams don’t need their midfielders to be controlling game states. The defenders can now do that instead, and bypass that defensive midfielder entirely – playing right to the players further up the field.

Think about Tottenham under De Zerbi as an example, where Jan Van Paul Hecke and Mickey van de Ven have made the 4th and 6th most passes per 90 in the league. Sandro Tonali meanwhile is rarely used out from the back in any scenario – almost told to get out of the way, as the defenders carry the ball out or pass to more talented ball-players further up the field.

Embed from Getty Images

Instead of being the one to spread nice passes around the pitch, Tonali is tasked with throwing himself into tackles, and anchoring the midfield down so that other players can work their magic in attack. In other words, his role is much more about what he does off the ball rather than on it.

Embed from Getty Images

Look no further than some of these images and the difference in size and strength between a player like Tonali (above) to Zubimendi, Gilmour or Morton (below). In the Premier League especially, it’s the Tonali’s and the Rice’s that are being prioritized.

Embed from Getty Images

So for many of these reasons, we’re seeing a complete decline of players in the Sergio Busquets mold. Those that can control games from deep on the field through their intelligence on the ball. Myles Lewis-Skelly is perhaps one of the most encouraging modern examples of a player that could break that notion, but he’s significantly more mobile in defense.

So for those that would have historically excelled as a Jorginho, Michael Carrick or Andrea Pirlo, they’re finding it increasingly difficult to make a mark at the highest level of the game.

Embed from Getty Images

In order to excel at the top end of the Premier League or Champions League, these new “deep-lying playmakers” must offer so much more, particularly in defensive knowhow, mobility and might.

Embed from Getty Images

Thanks for reading and see you soon.


Discover more from TheMastermindSite

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply